Stories

Tool Box vs. Drawer System: Which Is Better for Your Truck?

Rancher kneels on a DECKED Drawer System in a white 4x4 truck bed, sorting tools in an open tan DECKED case with the truck tool box open behind him.

A side-by-side look at the metal tool box, the DECKED Tool Box, and the Drawer System.

Default or Decision?

Most truck owners buy a metal tool box because it’s familiar, not because they compared it to anything. Time to make it a decision. Here’s how a traditional metal tool box stacks up against the DECKED Tool Box and Drawer System on organization, access, weight, security, weatherproofing, and cost.

Black pickup with an open DECKED truck tool box holding orange and green cases, firewood stacked in the bed, and a man running a chainsaw at the tailgate. Man on the tailgate of a tan pickup slides a DECKED case across the deck of an extended DECKED Drawer System, with climbing gear at his feet.

Metal Tool Box Problems

Diamond-plate boxes dent, warp, and corrode, and once a lid stops sealing, you own a very small above-ground pool. They also advertise: a shiny aluminum box tells thieves something’s worth stealing. Inside, it’s one open cavity where your tools pile up and the one you need is always on the bottom.

Meet the DECKED Tool Box

Does a DECKED Tool Box rust or dent? No. It’s compression-molded, fiber-reinforced resin: light as aluminum, strong as steel. The lid holds 300 lbs and the tub holds 800 lbs. A steel torsion box in the lid fights pry bars, a tamper-resistant lock handles the rest, and a one-touch button opens it with an elbow. It costs more than a basic metal box, but it’s built to move truck to truck for a lifetime.

Worker sets a red parts organizer into the sliding tray of an open DECKED truck tool box, with an orange case behind it and rain beading on the surface. Pallet of concrete blocks strapped down with blue DECKED ratchet straps on top of a DECKED Drawer System in a pickup bed.

Tool Box vs. Drawer System

Both are weatherproof, lockable, and tough. The real question is how you use your bed.

The Tool Box hugs the cab and leaves the rest open, so you keep full depth for tall, bulky loads. It also leaves open space for your gooseneck trailer. Elevated rails hold a Halfrack 32, Payloader 32, or Milwaukee PACKOUT™ for two-level storage.

The Drawer System adds a flat deck rated for 2,000 lbs on full-size trucks, with full-length drawers below. The trade: 12 inches of bed depth.

Contractor pulls open both drawers of a DECKED Drawer System in a white 4x4, with tools sorted in DECKED cases and a table saw strapped to the deck under a ladder rack. Rancher carries a green DECKED case away from a silver pickup with the lid of its DECKED truck tool box open behind him. Close-up of a weathered hand resting on the lid of a black DECKED truck tool box, with the lock visible on the side.

Access to Your Gear

With a metal box, you lean over the rail, reach past the struts, and dig. The DECKED Tool Box opens with a one-touch button, and its gas-strut linkage folds out of the way. The Drawer System rolls out to the tailgate, so gear at the front of the bed comes to you.

Close-up of a hand turning a key in the lock of a DECKED truck tool box. Close-up of the embossed DECKED logo on a rain-covered Drawer System deck. Hand pulls the aluminum handle to open a drawer on a DECKED Drawer System, with a chainsaw on the deck above.

Weatherproof and Secure

Rain, snow, and dust stay out. The Tool Box uses a sealed lid-to-tub design with the H2Zero Gasket. The Drawer System uses gaskets, weather strips, and protective panels. Both lock, and both keep gear out of sight.

Man storing orange DECKED halfrack in his drawer system in the garage. Man carrying DECKED orange halfrack in his garage.

Metal Box vs. DECKED Tool Box vs. Drawer System

METAL TOOLBOX

(LIGHTEST)
ORGANIZATION
One open cavity
ACCESS
Set everything down and figure it out
SECURITY
Pretty easy to get into once you put a good dent by the lid
WEATHERPROOFING
Fine—’til it gets dented
BED DEPTH
Maintained
COST
Lowest upfront — then you buy another and another and another...

DECKED TOOLBOX

(106 LBS)
ORGANIZATION
Trays, hooks, two-level storage
ACCESS
One-touch auto-open lid
SECURITY
Steel-reinforced lid, tamper-resistant lock
WEATHERPROOFING
H2Zero Gasket, no rust or dents
BED DEPTH
Maintained
COST
Higher upfront, No BS Lifetime Warranty

DECKED DRAWER SYSTEM

(171–283 LBS)
ORGANIZATION
Cases, Bins, Dividers, and more
ACCESS
Drawers roll out at the tailgate
SECURITY
Lockable, out of sight
WEATHERPROOFING
Gaskets, weather strips, panels
BED DEPTH
Minus 12 inches
COST
Highest upfront, most capacity, No BS Lifetime Warranty
Man organizing his orange DECKED payloader with the POD organization system in the back of his drawer system. Man storing tools in the back of his drawer system in customizable puzzlefoam. Man using DECKED bin with custom puzzlefoam for his power tools.

Which Fits Your Truck?

Choose the metal box for the lowest price — if you’re fine replacing it. Choose the Tool Box for tall, bulky hauls and secure storage up by the cab. Choose the Drawer System for a flat deck, full-length organization, and a 1,000-lb (midsize trucks) to 2,000-lb payload.

Got an eight-foot bed? Run both. The Drawer System and the Tool Box fit together, and CargoGlide can join the party, too.

Man storing gear in DECKED payloader in the bed of his truck on a snowy road in winter.

Tool Box FAQ

What’s the difference between a tool box and a Drawer System?

A tool box is one lockable compartment, usually near the cab. A Drawer System is a full set of drawers. The Tool Box keeps your bed depth. The Drawer System trades 12 inches of it for a flat deck and organized drawers.

Is a Drawer System better than a truck tool box?

Depends on your bed. Need a flat deck and lots of organized storage? Yes. Hauling tall, bulky loads? The Tool Box fits better.

Does DECKED’s Tool Box rust or dent like a metal one?

No. It’s compression-molded resin, so it won’t rust, dent, warp, or crack.

Can I use a tool box and a Drawer System together?

Yes, but only in an eight-foot bed.

Reading next

Person organizing outdoor gear in open DECKED storage cases in a truck bed.

Plastic Drawers in a Truck? Let’s Talk Durability.

Calling something “plastic” hasn't been an insult since the ‘80s.